English 301 Peer Review
please you must complete reviewing two drafts that i uploaded about half page peer review for each paper. this is only peer review to other students paper to improve the paper and where and how can they improve the paper
Peer Evaluation Checklist:
- Do they clearly state their main claim and identify their supporting claims in their introduction?
- Does each body paragraph have a clear supporting claim?
- Does each body paragraph have specific examples from the artifact(s)?
- Does each body paragraph have specific analysis of their examples?
- Do they make a final point in the end?
Responses to the following questions must be in complete sentences; brief responses or quick bullets will result in 0 credit.
Introduction:
- What are the strengths of the introduction?Why?
- What needs to be improved?How?Be specific.
- What are the strengths of the conclusion?Why?
- What needs to be improved?How?Be specific.
Body:
- What are the main strengths of the body?Why?Highlight at least one example to help the author understand what and why.
- Identify at least three areas, or representative areas, that need to be improved.
- Why do these need to be improved?
- How specifically can these be improved?
Conclusion:
Formatting:
- What are the strengths of the formatting?
- Does anything in the formatting need to be improved?How?
Which main three criteria from the Writing Portfolio Rubric do they do well in addressing?Why?
